Current:Home > ScamsOpponents use parental rights and anti-trans messages to fight abortion ballot measures-InfoLens
Opponents use parental rights and anti-trans messages to fight abortion ballot measures
View Date:2024-12-23 18:31:57
Follow live: Updates from AP’s coverage of the presidential election.
CHICAGO (AP) — Billboards with the words “STOP Child Gender Surgery.” Pamphlets warning about endangering minors. “PROTECT PARENT RIGHTS” plastered on church bulletins.
As voters in nine states determine whether to enshrine abortion rights in their state constitutions, opponents are using parental rights and anti-transgender messages to try to undermine support for the ballot proposals.
The measures do not mention gender-affirming surgeries, and legal experts say changing existing parental notification and consent laws regarding abortions and gender-affirming care for minors would require court action. But anti-abortion groups hoping to end a losing streak at the ballot box have turned to the type of language many Republican candidates nationwide are using in their own campaigns as they seek to rally conservative Christian voters.
“It’s really outlandish to suggest that this amendment relates to things like gender reassignment surgery for minors,” said Matt Harris, an associate professor of political science at Park University in Parkville, Missouri, a state where abortion rights are on the ballot.
Since the U.S. Supreme Court eliminated constitutional protections for abortion, voters in seven states, including conservative Kentucky, Montana and Ohio, have either protected abortion rights or defeated attempts to curtail them.
“If you can’t win by telling the truth, you need a better argument, even if that means capitalizing on the demonization of trans children,” said Dr. Alex Dworak, a family medicine physician in Omaha, Nebraska, where anti-abortion groups are using the strategy.
Tying abortion-rights ballot initiatives to parental rights and gender-affirming is a strategy borrowed from playbooks used in Michigan and Ohio, where voters nonetheless enshrined abortion rights in the state constitutions.
Both states still require minors to get parental consent for abortions, and the new amendments have not yet impacted parental involvement or gender-affirming care laws in either state, said David Cohen, a law professor at Drexel University.
“It’s just recycling the same strategies,” Cohen said.
In addition to Missouri and Nebraska, states where voters are considering constitutional amendments this fall are Montana, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland, Nevada and South Dakota.
Missouri’s abortion ballot measure has especially become a target. The amendment would bar the government from infringing on a “person’s fundamental right to reproductive freedom.”
Gov. Mike Parson and U.S. Sen. Josh Hawley, both Republicans, have claimed the proposal would allow minors to get abortions and gender-affirming surgeries without parental involvement.
The amendment protects reproductive health services, “including but not limited to” a list of items such as prenatal care, childbirth, birth control and abortion. It does not mention gender-affirming care, but Missouri state Sen. Mary Elizabeth Coleman, a Republican and lawyer with the conservative Thomas More Society, said it’s possible that could be considered reproductive health services.
Several legal experts told The Associated Press that would require a court ruling that is improbable.
What to know about the 2024 Election
- Today’s news: Follow live updates from the campaign trail from the AP.
- Elections, explained: We answer your election questions.
- Ground Game: Sign up for AP’s weekly politics newsletter to get it in your inbox every Monday.
- AP’s Role: The Associated Press is the most trusted source of information on election night, with a history of accuracy dating to 1848. Learn more.
“It would be a real stretch for any court to say that anything connected with gender-affirming care counts as reproductive health care,” said Saint Louis University law and gender studies professor Marcia McCormick. She noted that examples listed as reproductive health care in the Missouri amendment are all directly related to pregnancy.
As for parental consent for minors’ abortions, she pointed to an existing state law that is written similarly to one the U.S. Supreme Court found constitutional, even before Roe v. Wade was overturned.
Most states have parental involvement laws, whether requiring parental consent or notification. Even many Democratic-leaning states with explicit protections for transgender rights require parental involvement before an abortion or gender-affirming care for minors, said Mary Ruth Ziegler, a law professor at the University of California, Davis School of Law.
A state high court would have to overturn such laws, which is highly unlikely from conservative majorities in many of the states with abortion on the ballot, experts said.
In New York, a proposed amendment to the state constitution would expand antidiscrimination protections to include ethnicity, national origin, age, disability and “sex, including sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes, and reproductive health care and autonomy.” The constitution already bans discrimination based on race, color, creed or religion.
The measure does not mention abortion. But because it is broader, it could be easier for opponents to attack it. But legal experts noted that it would also not change existing state laws related to parental involvement in minors getting abortions or gender-affirming care.
The New York City Bar Association released a fact-sheet explaining that the measure would not impact parental rights, “which are governed by other developed areas of State and federal law.” Yet the Coalition to Protect Kids-NY calls it the “Parent Replacement Act.”
Rick Weiland, co-founder of Dakotans for Health, the group behind South Dakota ‘s proposed amendment said it uses the Roe v. Wade framework “almost word for word.”
“All you have to do is look back at what was allowed under Roe, and there were always requirements for parental involvement,” Weiland said.
Caroline Woods, spokesperson for the anti-abortion group Life Defense Fund, said the measure “means loving parents will be completely cut out of the equation.” Weiland said those claims are part of a “constant stream of misinformation” from opponents.
If this campaign strategy failed in Michigan and Ohio, why are anti-abortion groups leaning on it for the November elections?
Ziegler, the University of California, Davis law professor, said abortion-rights opponents know they may be “playing on more favorable terrain” in more conservative states like Missouri or in states like Florida that have higher thresholds for passing ballot measures.
“Anti-abortion groups are still looking for a winning recipe,” Ziegler said.
___
Associated Press writer Geoff Mulvihill in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, contributed to this report.
___
The Associated Press receives support from several private foundations to enhance its explanatory coverage of elections and democracy. See more about AP’s democracy initiative here. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
veryGood! (88)
Related
- Tua Tagovailoa playing with confidence as Miami Dolphins hope MNF win can spark run
- College Football Playoff ranking snubs: Who got slighted during first release?
- 7-year-old's killer gets 60 years to life. He asked for a longer sentence.
- Elmo, other Sesame Street characters send heartwarming messages ahead of Election Day
- Kentucky governor says investigators will determine what caused deadly Louisville factory explosion
- Why AP called Florida for Trump
- AP Race Call: Republican Gus Bilirakis wins reelection to U.S. House in Florida’s 12th Congressional District
- Clemson football coach Dabo Swinney tried to vote but couldn't on Election Day
- Watch as dust storm that caused 20-car pileup whips through central California
- Tyka Nelson, sister of late music icon Prince, dies at 64: Reports
Ranking
- Larry Hobbs, who guided AP’s coverage of Florida news for decades, has died at 83
- Pregnant Gypsy Rose Blanchard Reveals Who Fathered Her Baby After Taking Paternity Test
- Who Are Ella Emhoff and Cole Emhoff? Everything to Know About Vice President Kamala Harris’ Step-Kids
- Republican Rep. Michael Guest won reelection to a U.S. House seat representing Mississippi
- Chicago Bears will ruin Caleb Williams if they're not careful | Opinion
- Gap Outlet’s Early Black Friday Secret Deals Include Stylish Finds Starting at $6 – Save Up to 60%
- CAUCOIN Trading Center: Shaping the Future Financial Market Through NFT and Digital Currency Synergy
- Ben Affleck praises 'spectacular' performance by Jennifer Lopez in 'Unstoppable'
Recommendation
-
Homes of Chiefs’ quarterback Mahomes and tight end Kelce were broken into last month
-
Jennifer Love Hewitt Says This 90s Trend Is the Perfect Holiday Present and Shares Gift-Giving Hacks
-
2 police officers are shot and injured at Kentucky mental health center
-
Rapper Tekashi 6ix9ine strikes deal to end jail stint
-
Will Trump’s hush money conviction stand? A judge will rule on the president-elect’s immunity claim
-
Los Angeles News Anchor Chauncy Glover Dead at 39
-
No grand prize Powerball winner Monday, but a ticket worth $1M sold in California
-
Trump likely to target climate measures that are making the most difference